![]() |
He's not Luger, but he could be just as special Photo Credit: WWE.com |
All Elite Wrestling debuted its flagship television show, Dynamite, last night, and overall, I thought it was a mostly complete success with a few quibbles. You couldn't ask for a better start. From the opening title to the close with chaos in the ring, they put their best foot forward. It's time to dive into the action.
Cody Rhodes: Wife Guy - The first match for Dynamite on TNT wasn't Brian Pillman, Jr. vs. Jushin Liger like some postulated (and Tony Schiavone was sure to shout the match between Liger and Pillman's dad out), but Cody vs. Sammy Guevara, an incredible opportunity for a wrestler in the latter who achieved moderate indie fame and some exposure in one of Mexico's top promotions. While the framing for the match was the definition of milquetoast (Guevara's "don't overlook me!" shtick made for blunted expectations), the match itself was exciting and tense. While Guevara felt his nerves a bit with a few slips on high flying moves, where he hit his spots, they were impressive. Cody again settled into cosplay-of-his-father mode, which continues to work for him.
The most notable development during the match, however, was the revelation that Cody is a
wife guy. Brandi, who accompanied him to the ring, was just as much a part of the match as Cody and Guevara, concentrated mostly on one sequence towards the end. Cody dumped Guevara to the outside, and Brandi started to jaw at him. As Cody attempted a tope suicida to the outside, Guevara pulled Brandi in his path. When Cody went to check on her, Guevara attacked. So now Cody is the "accidently dove onto his wife guy." More pointedly, the whole sequence highlighted that AEW still has problems with presentation. Obviously, Cody is a face, and I'm not sure any old school cocky heel stuff that coming from the executive vice president and chief brand officer seems like entitled one percent shit would make the fans not cheer him on the first night. However, there's edgy face stuff, and then there's arrogance reserved for heels. I would not have Brandi mock opponents going forward, but that's just me. If the cheers start to turn into boos as the weeks go on, well, I'll just have to say I told you so.
I will give Cody all the credit in the world for how close to the vest he played the match. It could have easily been a squash, but like with the Darby Allin match at Fyter Fest, Cody gave the less-established Guevara a lot to hang his hat upon, which will come in handy later given how the show ended and how Guevara is part of Chris Jericho's anti-Elite faction. At the time, it seemed like wrong place, wrong time for Guevara wanting a handshake before Jericho jumped Cody and wailed on him through the picture-in-picture brawl during commercials. But as it turned out it was foreshadowing.
It's in the Way That You Use It - Speaking of squashes, poor Brandon Cutler didn't have a chance against MJF, but honestly, the match was the least interesting part of the segment, at least with regards to The Discourse™. MJF obviously has gotten a lot of attention and been the center of many an online scuffle, but the most germane surround his ability to draw heat. People on one side want to denigrate him because he dips into the cheap heat inkwell a lot, which is undoubtedly true. Nothing he's saying is particularly groundbreaking, but not everyone can be a Jake Roberts-level of wordsmith. What makes MJF work is his delivery, his confidence, his swagger, and his body language. A lot of heels have that going for them. You can't be a slumping, slouching heel speaking meekly and expect people to boo you with the tenacity of a thousand junkyard dogs. That's how MJF works.
Snoochie Boochies - As an unabashed fan of Kevin Smith, it was great to see him at Dynamite with Jay Mewes. Yeah, Smith might be an early Aughts phenomenon and totally not on the cutting edge, but hey, Jericho's in his new movie. OF course he's gonna be there. And Smith stayed past his mic spot, which is nice. It also set up Jack Evans to become an even bigger villain than MJF by dissing Morris Day and the Time. What kind of monster doesn't like Morris Day and the Time? Either way, the match that will come out of that altercation, Private Party vs. Evans and Angelico, should be fantastic.
The Manlet Tyrant - PAC vs. Adam Page was a match that was promised from Double or Nothing but had to be cancelled thanks to Dragon Gate obligations for the former and an injury for the latter. They tangled at the end of hour one into hour two on the first episode of Dynamite, and outside of some questionable pacing, I thought it was a decent-at-worst match. Page looked the best he had been in AEW here, putting extra mustard behind his big moves and exerting his size. You might think PAC, all 5'8" and 206 pounds, wouldn't be able to project such a dominant presence as a miserable heel working on top most of the match, especially given how much size he gives up to the Hangman. The crowd work was a nice touch too. For someone who has spent most of his career before his turn in WWE as an exciting white meat babyface, seeing him seethe and glower has been a treat. Nailing a low blow out of Earl Hebner's sightline was a nice touch as well. He appears to be headed for something big, as he has wins over two of the members of the Elite now. Whether he's in line for a World Title shot (which seems unlikely unless Jericho drops it to Cody at Full Gear) or if he'll be the first holder of a future secondary title, they are high on PAC, as they should be.
Questionable Choices in the Women's Division - So, Riho is AEW's first Women's Champion after a war with Nyla Rose. Although Rose towers over Riho, the match worked because it was mostly cat and mouse, if the mouse had lethal elbows and knees. It was a smart choice to have Riho's offense mostly come in the form of stiff strikes and moves assisted by rope momentum or height off the top rope. They're both smart workers as much as they are athletic or hard-hitting. I'll still never expect seeing Rose do that leaping knee to an opponent from the corner halfway across the ring either. It was the best match of the night, and it set a great tone for the division until you got to the finish.
I'm not saying Riho is a bad first Champion, but they had a chance to make a statement by having Rose be the first standardbearer in the division. It might not have been as bad until after, when Rose attacked Michael Nakazawa, who was interviewing the victorious Riho. They had Kenny Omega make the save, which teased intergender wrestling. In a vacuum, that would have been great, but the way they teased Omega getting into it with Rose felt like a half-measure to appeal to
TERFs. All in all, it's a very centrist activist way of doing things. You put the trans woman in the main event, have her lose, and then start teasing that she'll fight a man because of how she was born. I don't want to believe that's the case, but the circumstances all lined up in dubious ways. I guess I'll have to wait and see.
OUCH - The Omega/Jon Moxley brawl was the best thing on the show (non-match) for two reasons. Omega, the Cleaner, fought Moxley with a mop, and then at the end, Mox Death Rider'd him through a glass table. There's not much else to say other than AEW should definitely put the whole thing on YouTube. If you want to differentiate yourself from WWE, that kind of visceral violence is what you need.
Jake "Lex Luger" Hager - The final brawl after the main event did a great job setting up the battle lines for the future. Gang warfare is best played out in wrestling for a reason. The fronts set up as you might expect with the surprise of Jake "Jack Swagger" Hager as Jericho's final hammer. It was met to mixed reactions, which makes sense. As Swagger, Hager left WWE with a trail of injuries behind him. He was also the presumable last Lucha Underground Champion, one that was met with indifference. That being said, as one of the few people who liked him in Lucha Underground and as someone who remembered when he was a blue chip prospect in WWE ECW, I think this could work.
OF course, people compared his entrance to Luger's at the first Nitro, and that's silly. Hager wasn't going back to WWE, and no, he didn't "con Vince." His entrance hearkened back to that Luger entrance, but if I'm being real, Moxley was the Lex Luger appearance. He just happened to make his debut months before television began. Not everything is symmetrical, nor should it be. World Championship Wrestling made a lot of mistakes, and while there's a lot to love from those days in WCW, well, Cody and the gang would be wise not to repeat them.